Texas Governor-elect Gina Hinojosa has promised to freeze residential electricity rates and halt data center approvals until the Legislature acts. Will the new Democratic governor of Texas have the juice to make it so?
Gov. Greg Abbott already paused approvals for large data center electricity loads pending an audit of the data centers by ERCOT.
Come January, Democrats will control the governor’s office, the lieutenant governor’s office and the Texas House. Republicans keep control of the Texas Senate, which confirms the governor’s appointees, including members of the Public Utility Commission of Texas, and writes the rules that give the lieutenant governor most of the office’s power.
On this week’s Energy Capital Podcast, Joshua Rhodes talks with Eric Goff, who heads the advocacy and advisory firm Goff Policy, about what the new officeholders can do alone and what the election means across the Texas grid. We recorded with Goff on Nov. 14.
The rest of the conversation:
The rate freeze: in ERCOT’s competitive retail areas, Goff says the governor could only affect transmission and distribution rates, which are set via rate cases tied to utility costs. He reads the promise as a push to lower residential bills.
The moratorium: “We have a limited government in Texas,” Goff says, and an executive order depends on the agency carrying it out. He would let projects under construction connect while ERCOT finishes its batch zero review process, which he expects to run past the session.
Who pays for transmission: the PUCT has proposed replacing 4CP, which assigns transmission costs by demand at ERCOT’s peak in each of four summer months, with monthly peaks (12CP) and a minimum charge for large loads. Goff says enough data centers on those terms would more than pay for the lines built for them.
SB 293: Senate Finance Chair Joan Huffman’s bill to repeal the data center sales tax exemption has 23 of 31 current and incoming senators signed on. Goff warns sales and property taxes together would put Texas development costs well above other states.
765-kV lines: Goff calls Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick the leading backer of new approval rules and expects less appetite since he lost reelection. Goff would fix utility notices, which he says landowners testified came in unmarked white envelopes, and give complex cases more than 180 days.
DRRS: Goff once pushed for the dispatchable reliability reserve service (reserve power from plants that can start within two hours) and now regrets writing an ancillary service into state law.
Plus: whether Democrats have a mandate, how ERCOT’s board is chosen, DRRS plus, renewables and storage, home batteries, large loads tripping offline, the Railroad Commission, Texas Commission on Environmental Quality and the Water Development Board, and federal permitting reform.
Chapters:
00:00 – Introduction
01:10 – What Texas voters were saying
03:12 – The lieutenant governor’s power
06:59 – A Democratic House, a Republican Senate
08:30 – Can Hinojosa freeze electricity rates?
11:40 – Abbott’s pause vs. a data center moratorium
14:22 – Who Hinojosa can appoint at the PUC and ERCOT
20:39 – The future of data centers in Texas
26:04 – Can data centers pay their own way?
30:06 – Ending data center tax breaks
31:31 – Texas’s new 765-kV power lines
34:25 – Renewables, batteries, and backup power
39:07 – When data centers drop off the grid
41:26 – Other Texas agencies and Washington
Resources:
People & Organizations
Company & Industry News
Goff Policy - Former PUCT Commissioner Shelly Botkin and Daniel Willard join the firm
KPRC - Could Texas Republicans strip power from the new lieutenant governor?
Texas Monthly - Can Gina Hinojosa lower Texans’ electricity bills?
Texas Tribune - What Hinojosa’s win means for the data center pause
Books, Articles & Filings Discussed
PUCT Project No. 58000 - Proposal to replace 4CP with 12CP and set large load minimum billing demand
Office of the Governor - Directive for a comprehensive data center audit
ERCOT - PGRR 145, Batch Zero process for large load interconnections
ERCOT - New batch connection process, including the WLPUN and PCLR pathways
Piq Energy and Base Power - Flexibility without Curtailment study
SB 293 (90th Legislature) - Repeal of data center sales tax exemptions
SB 2 (87th Legislature) - ERCOT governance and the Board Selection Committee
ERCOT - NOGRR 282, Large computational load ride-through requirements
ERCOT - Interim voltage ride-through assessment for existing large loads
Related Podcasts by Energy Capital
Related Posts by Texas Energy & Power
Transcript:
Joshua Rhodes: Hey, everyone, and welcome to another episode of the Energy Capital Podcast. I’m really excited to have Eric Goff back to talk about kind of what the blue wave means for Texas. Eric Goff is the founder of Goff Policy, which is a Texas energy and infrastructure consulting shop based in Austin, Texas. And he recently put out a report, letter, kind of on this exact topic, what this means, and he was generous enough to share that with us, and so now we’re gonna, you know, talk through that here. And so, Eric, welcome to the Energy Capital Podcast.
Eric Goff: Happy to be here. Thanks for having me back.
Joshua Rhodes: Eric, you must have a lot of work going on and a lot of demands on your time. One, ‘cause we had to record this on a Saturday, which is totally fine, but I feel like on LinkedIn all the time I’m seeing, “Hey, everyone, I’ve joined Goff Policy for, you know, this, that, or the other.” So how big is your team now? Where are all y’all working?
Eric Goff: Yeah. We’ve got a growing team. We’ve got people based mostly in Austin, but also in Maine and Colorado, and former Commissioner Shelly Botkin, Daniel Willard will be joining us starting on Monday to do more policy work.
Joshua Rhodes: Wow. Man, you’re building a powerhouse team over there. So looking forward to hearing more out of you guys. Let’s get into it. So we kinda just dove into it right off the bat, but, you know, the 2026 election, particularly in Texas, I mean, it was a major change in Texas politics, right? What do you think voters were actually saying, and how much of what they were saying do you think was related to energy?
Eric Goff: Yeah. I think that’s a really good question. So fundamentally, you know, the most predictable thing in elections is if the economy is doing badly, the incumbent party is going to underperform. And there’s a lot of activity around energy leading up to the election, I would say mostly in the diesel and gasoline markets, but I think definitely was a contributing factor. We’ve seen rising costs. We heard a lot of questions from people and intense opposition to data centers, but in the polling I saw, I don’t think that was anyone’s top issue, but it certainly didn’t help either.
Joshua Rhodes: Yeah. I think immediately the next day, I got a bunch of questions from reporters, yeah, basically asking, “What does blue wave mean for data centers in Texas?” And then the next question was, “Should Democrats feel like they have a mandate in Texas?” I was saying no. I was saying they have a trial period, but I’m curious what you think.
Eric Goff: Trial period’s a great way to say it. The Democrats have been out of power for decades, my entire adult life, and there were many people who won with huge numbers that had no campaigns, that had very little name ID. So it was, I think, a rejection of the current direction and as much national issues as state issues. You know, there was a national trend. Texas wasn’t the only state to go blue, so it’s hard to tell a story that it’s a uniquely Texas situation. But the top of the ticket with federal Senate race, I think, certainly played a role with turnout.
Joshua Rhodes: Yeah, you’re right. It wasn’t just Texas. I think we just found out a day or so ago that Mississippi is also sending a Democratic senator to the federal government, which has not happened in a while. Let’s come back into Texas before we’re kinda zooming back out. So now that Democrats are gonna have, you know, control of some of the highest offices in the state, they’re gonna have to quickly pivot from campaign to governance. And we’ll get to governor, but, like, I don’t think a lot of people realize that at least maybe until recently, the lieutenant governor actually held some of the most power across the state. So Vikki Goodwin is gonna be inheriting a position typically considered one of the most powerful in Texas. Can you talk about what the lieutenant governor does or how she will work in the current state?
Eric Goff: Yeah. So Dan Patrick ran that office, you know, from a instruments of power perspective, he was good at being lieutenant governor. He knew his power. He knows how the Senate works. He knows what, you know, the Republican primary voters want and, you know, was hyper-focused on delivering and using the instruments of his office. So I would say he’s probably been one of the most powerful lieutenant governors we’ve had in modern times. And many politicians that don’t know how power works, which is kinda funny, but if you use your power in ways that, you know, support your coalition or a broader group, then you get more power. So people talk about spending political capital, but the metaphor with capital is that it grows. That’s, I think, why we refer to as political capital or that political money or something. So in that context, the Senate was, you know, very organized and had centralized power in him and his office. And just before the election, you know, there were stories in Quorum Report about how Senate Republicans were preparing for if he lost, they would rewrite the rules, which reported again after the election that they met and are talking about it. We’ll see what they do and how far they go. You know, the Texas Legislature historically, but less so the Texas Senate recently, has had a history of bipartisanship. And it’s certainly gonna be necessary to govern, given that the Senate stayed Republican. So I’m curious to see, you know, how far into taking away Lieutenant Governor-elect Goodwin’s powers they’ll go.
Joshua Rhodes: Yeah, ‘cause I think the flip side of that coin that most people, if they knew that the lieutenant governor was one of, if not the most powerful elected official, it was a lot of that power was given to that seat by the Senate. And they can just take it away just by kinda rewriting the rules, right?
Eric Goff: Yeah. There’s a lot of power within the rules. There are some things that the lieutenant governor can do on her own. We’ll get to it later, but appoint someone to the ERCOT Board Selection Committee. But, you know, they’ll certainly do that. There are a number of Republicans in the Senate that are in districts that weren’t up for reelection, but are in two years in districts where James Talarico won. And so, you know, those senators might be interested in focusing on what they need to do to win reelection, and the two ways to go with that are, you know, to be hard-nosed and lean into the values that, you know, they’ve run on historically, and the other’s to try to be more conciliatory. And I think that’ll be the major story is whether or not the Republican Senate is working with the Democratic leadership in the House and in the executive offices, or if they’ll try to block them, you know, in a way that, you know, typically happens when you have a lack of bipartisanship. Obviously, I’m sure they’re not satisfied having lost statewide elections and wanna get back into power. At the same time, there’s a lot that’s on the line to decide in the next few years about how the state’s gonna grow, and so it’ll be a balancing act.
Joshua Rhodes: Yeah, absolutely. And so, yeah, while the Texas Senate stayed in Republican control, but the Texas House has now flipped to Democratic control. And so what will that mean for Democratic control of the Texas State House? Like, practically in terms of committees and other types of stuff, legislation, like, what will that look like and how will that interact with, like, the Republican Senate?
Eric Goff: So for decades, the Texas State House has operated in a bipartisan fashion and did recently as under Republican control, where Republican speakers were elected with Democratic support for many years and allowed, you know, Democrats to have some amount of leadership within the different committees, and that led to times when there was collaboration and times when there weren’t. So we heard James Talarico talk on the campaign trail about all the bills he passed, right? And that happened because, you know, he was able to cooperate, you know, with Republican majorities. And the flip side of that coin is that the Republican majorities were interested in doing that. So I’m expecting the same thing from the Democratic leadership in the House, and we saw that when the new speaker announced that she had enough votes, there were a number of Republican senior officials that were with her, and then many former speakers are advising her in the transition. So I think that they’ll operate on a bipartisan basis, and, you know, just the way counting works, they won’t be able to pass any bills unless the Senate, you know, also passes them, and vice versa.
Joshua Rhodes: I’ve been asked about this too, and I was like, “Well, there’s kinda two options. There’s either you work together or deadlock.” Like, I mean, that’s kind of how it is. Let’s talk about what Governor-elect Hinojosa can actually do on day one, and what actions would be required by the legislature or other regulatory agencies. She’s talked about freezing electricity rates and stopping data center approvals until new protections are in place. But, you know, what authority does the governor have on those things, particularly in, you know, Texas’s competitive electricity market?
Eric Goff: Yeah. So Texas’s competitive electricity market means that in areas where there’s competition, prices are set based on retailers that are competing against each other to offer the best prices. That’s the theory. If people don’t switch, they don’t always get the advantage of that. And so make sure you go to Power to Choose website to check your rates if you’re in the competitive areas. So the process to freeze rates can only be on the distribution and transmission rates, and those are set in rate cases. So the way that they could do that would be to go through rate cases, through DCRFs, through TCRFs, and even then those costs have to reflect the actual cost that the utility is getting. And if you don’t allow them to recover their costs, you know, there are potentially issues where they could appeal that and say it’s not following the way the law works. And so the way that I interpret that therefore must be that she was talking about rates as a way to quickly get her point across, because it would be difficult to say, “Well, I understand there’s a retail electric market, and the retail electric market...” That wouldn’t be a good soundbite. So I think she must necessarily be talking about trying to bring down residential costs because that’s what is contributing to inflation. And there are lots of ways to do that. On day one, you can tell the utility commission to start looking into options and, you know, hopefully during the transition she’ll be developing further details around things that drive costs and that could drive costs down. So a big one is transmission costs by moving to 12CP. There is data that Oncor published recently that showed that’ll lower cost compared to 4CP. I know all of your listeners know what that is, right?
Joshua Rhodes: Yeah. So I mean, with like the four coincident peak, you know, is like the amount of load-serving entity pays for the transmission network is, you know, how much of that network they were holding during the highest 15-minute interval from June, July, August, and September for the next year. Did I get that mostly right?
Eric Goff: Yep. And so if we move to 12CP, there’ll be more samples. It would be more difficult to avoid, and according to the Oncor data and other data that’s been published, will contribute to lowering transmission costs. There’s also a proposal for minimum transmission charges to also lower transmission costs, and I think we talked about that last time, so I won’t dwell on it. But that’s a way to make sure the data centers don’t have a way to avoid paying that cost because there’s a minimum they get billed for.
Joshua Rhodes: Yeah, our last conversation was a lot about Batch Zero and then also some of this, like, cost allocation stuff, so I’d encourage listeners to go back and listen to that, and we’ll put it in the show notes. Another thing that the governor-elect has talked about is, you know, kind of stopping new data center approvals or putting a moratorium, which sounds a little more harsh than a pause that Governor Abbott had kind of put on. So in your mind, is there a difference between the pause and the moratorium? And if so, how should we think about those?
Eric Goff: A question that I got a lot from data center developers before the election was, you know, is Governor Abbott’s pause just politics? And clearly it wasn’t because people were hearing on the campaign trail on both sides, and by the end of the campaign, the lieutenant governor, Dan Patrick, was apparently putting out door hangers that said he wanted a moratorium on data centers. So the issue there is there’s approved rules that are being executed on in order to implement Batch Zero. And the pause was to do additional surveys about the community impact and, you know, the ERCOT received a letter from the governor and the PUC received a letter from the governor. The best way to characterize it is they chose to comply with the requests in the letter, right? The ability to do executive orders is certainly possible, but it has to be executed on by that agency, and there’s a kind of a limited ability to do that. We have a limited government in Texas. And so I think just like everything else, it’ll have to be based on some amount of cooperation and, like, shared intention. We know that both parties have said they want to get a better handle on data centers, and so there might be a willingness to figure out how to cooperate on that. And practically, there are kinda two sets of data centers that are at issue. Those that are, like, ready to energize now and have, like, active construction crews building them, but are waiting for ERCOT, you know, energization approval. And if you pause that, you know, those construction crews will probably all get fired, right? Then the other ones are ones that are waiting for Batch Zero approval, which is months away. And so I think the middle way might be letting those currently under construction data centers that were anticipating connecting soon to connect. They’ll have to sign the standard large load interconnection agreement. And then practically, Batch Zero won’t be done until after the legislative session. So ERCOT can work on those studies, a law can be passed, and, you know, if the law affects the study, so be it, right?
Joshua Rhodes: Yeah. Every conversation now is about, you know, data centers, and we’ll just throw AI in there too, just for fun. From the governor-elect, she has the ability to appoint, I think something like 3,000, you know, seats across the state of Texas. Not all at once. She can’t wholesale fire someone without cause if someone already has kinda that seat. But not everyone’s seat is maybe as secure as maybe one would think. So how quickly could the composition and direction of the Public Utility Commission change under the new administration?
Eric Goff: So the governor’s power to appoint is one of her key powers that she’ll have, and that and the veto pen. So a governor’s power tends to accrue over time, which is, you know, why Governor Abbott, you know, was also a powerful governor, is because all of his appointees were in charge of every agency that he had appointment power over. And they were willing to cooperate with him because they have worked together for a long time. There are a few commissioners that would need to be up for confirmation, two of them, and so if they weren’t confirmed, then the governor would have an opportunity to, you know, put two people there. But they could be confirmed still. Then there are a few other terms that expire in ‘27, and one that have to be reappointed and also reconfirmed. And many of the people that are on the utility commission, I would say all of them are interested in public service. We’re really fortunate to have a very good commission and have had a very good commission for a long time. And I’m not just saying that because I, you know, need to talk to them, but we’ve generally had good outcomes from them, right? I think that civic-mindedness, they want the energy market in Texas to function and to deliver good outcomes. And so some of them might be willing to, you know, step aside early in exchange for, you know, consideration of their other colleagues that are on the commission or, you know, there might be some that wanna stick around because they believe in what they’re doing. You know, you could cynically say that, you know, people would try to be blocking her and practically, I don’t think that her views are on energy are outside of the mainstream. I don’t think there’s a need to block something. And so it’ll be subject to negotiation, and we’ll have to see how it goes. There’ll be much broader effects across all the agencies because people will have to go through Senate confirmation. It’ll be a negotiation with the existing office holders and the Senate about which agencies turn over and which ones don’t. And it— so it’s much bigger than the energy in industry about which ones are people willing to concede and which ones are people not willing to concede. But, you know, in theory, she could have zero seats available in the near term, all the way to three seats, which would be a majority in the near term. Maybe even more, you know, if people were willing to be conciliatory. And her appointments, like we said, would have to go through Republican Senate confirmation. And so if they fail to do that, they wouldn’t hold office, but she could appoint kind of in the interim between sessions, too.
Joshua Rhodes: Yeah. Okay. But the governor can appoint the chair of the PUC, right? Like, the chair serves at the pleasure of the governor, right? So regardless of which five are there, she can choose who the chair will be, right?
Eric Goff: Yeah. And we’ve had strong chairs that are leaders of the commission, but they don’t have any special powers other than, you know, running the meeting. There’s like a sense of, like, camaraderie among them, so they are deferential to the chair. The chair has one vote of five votes.
Joshua Rhodes: Okay. Fair enough. And so turning to the ERCOT board, I actually had to look this up the other day because I didn’t realize that there was, like, a committee that was put together by appointees that then chose, like, the ERCOT board members. Like, it was like a multi-step process. It wasn’t just, like, the governor. Are you able to walk through kind of like how would governance at ERCOT change or, like, how could that change?
Eric Goff: So ironically, ERCOT is something called an independent system operator, or ISO, and that comes from a long history of saying, you know, these things need to be independent of politics. And so Texas set up ERCOT to be a Texas nonprofit corporation. And then over time, there have been lawsuits that say, well, in some cases they’re an agency, in other cases they’re not, and that’s developed over time. And then after Winter Storm Uri, the board, you know, many of them resigned or they were fired eventually, and a new bill, SB 2, passed that made ERCOT have zero stakeholders from the industry on the board. It used to be they had a minority of the seats, and a majority were for independent directors. And that bill said, you know, a number of things. It said there can only be no more than two professors on the ERCOT board, so watch out. It also said people had to be from Texas. Our former board chair was from Minnesota, which I think personally would have been great to have someone that was familiar with the cold weather as we were reforming ERCOT. And the ERCOT board, it’s been politically appointed, so what you were referring to was the ERCOT Board Selection Committee, and the governor appoints someone, the lieutenant governor appoints someone, and the speaker of the House appoints someone. And then they’re required to hire a consulting company to help them do, you know, selection. So I think, like, a search firm is what they mean by that. But they don’t have to follow the advice of that search firm necessarily, and they can appoint who they wanna appoint. Those board members are also have terms that are established by the ERCOT bylaws. But a key question will be what dictates their terms? Is it the group in state law that says, “This is the Board Selection Committee,” or is it the terms that are in the ERCOT bylaws? There are different people who have different opinions about that because that’s such a new law, it’s not really tested. There’s no need to figure out if someone could be fired from the ERCOT board or not. So we’ll see.
Joshua Rhodes: Got it. Yeah. No, it’s, yeah, a lot of things I’ve also had to learn, like, you know, about who appoints who, ‘cause it’s always never had to know that, but now it’s a good thing to know. We’ve touched on data centers and large load growth, but let’s talk a little bit more about them. So data centers, I think, you know, we’ve already said were on the ballot. It’s kind of one of the more bipartisan issues in terms of, you know, pushback on data centers. What do you think the future of data center development in Texas looks like?
Eric Goff: Yeah. A lot of people have said, myself included, that data centers need to kind of reestablish their social license. There’s just been intense pushback, and I think a lot of the pushback, in some part it comes from, you know, community impact, but it’s also just broader concerns about people’s uncertainty around AI. So we’re recording the day after the FAA grounded all the flights, and people were circulating about how the FAA installed some new AI software the day before. We’ll see if that’s what led to anything, but, you know, people naturally just assume that AI software has issues, and that’s a bigger problem that you can’t resolve by saying the setback from data centers has to be 100 feet from the property line or whatever, right? No matter what the setback is, it’s not gonna improve somebody’s opinion about AI. Both those issues have led to some dissatisfaction, and ERCOT, though, is one of the few places where data centers have had a realistic and large-scale path forward, and there’s a lot that’s tied up in the American and global economy because, like it or not, so many companies are pivoting to AI because there’s such a clear demand for AI. Whether you like it or not, there’s a huge demand for it. So those data centers are worth a lot of money. Things that are worth a lot of money that are property can be taxed, and you have to install things in them that could get, you know, sales and use tax assigned if we change the law. And that enormous amount of revenue can cut taxes, it can pay for schools, it can pay for healthcare. And I think that’s the path forward, is figure out a way to identify development rules in the law, have a way for data centers to pay their fair share of taxes, and then use that tax revenue to do things. I’ll take a quick pause after this one thing, which is, I think what Democrats learned from the Biden’s IRA bill is you need to have laws that you pass and impacts that affect people’s material conditions right away. And the sooner that you can have those impacts, the sooner people understand the consequence of the election. So I think the Hinojosa administration and the rest of Democrats are gonna be looking for, you know, material impacts quickly, and that’s hard to do sometimes, but taxes are something that you can get pretty quickly.
Joshua Rhodes: Yeah. Well, in terms of like, you know, timelines, you know, she’s called for like kinda moratorium until the legislature acts. I’m not sure if that’s the exact word that she used, but like, I don’t know if legislature acts means like passes a law, or then laws have to get to her desk. There’s kind of this like gauntlet that laws run through in May, kinda right before the end. So can we get a range for like it could be like May, or it could be September when like usually these laws are like coming into effect?
Eric Goff: Yeah. So that’s a really good question, and it’s one that’s hard to answer. There could be the results of the community audit could be provided to the legislature and the governor, and they might, you know, on the most optimistic case, see that, you know, in many cases these data centers are developing according to the standards they would have passed anyway. Practically, again, because Batch Zero is on a timeline to be done after the legislature, a moratorium might be kinda meaningless, right? Because if people are just doing this study at ERCOT but not issuing approval until later, we could be on a similar timeline to what people were already expecting from Batch Zero, but with, you know, more oversight of what happens, right? If the Batch Zero results, you know, we’ll get after the legislature, maybe even after September for the final report, that’s in line with the legislative outcomes, right? So the big question will be, will ERCOT be able to continue to do their studies while the legislature is meeting? And, you know, I think that Texas can walk and chew gum at the same time.
Joshua Rhodes: Right. Okay. If you gauge like approvals being kind of that last step of the Batch Zero process where like, okay, here’s your allocation of power over time, and here’s the transmission plan that we need to support that, that was already gonna be kind of mid at best, probably late 2027, right?
Eric Goff: Yeah. So the pause would delay that study, and if you assume that there’s a one-for-one day delay from the number of days of the pause to the number of days it’ll take to pick it back up again, you don’t get that preliminary report until August. Now, maybe ERCOT will be able to do it sooner. Hopefully, they will. But regardless, they were scheduled in April, which is around the time that we get into the gauntlet of the legislature. So if it takes like another couple of months to another few months, you know, that’s plenty of time for the legislature to meet, decide what to do, and pass a bill, and for her to sign it.
Joshua Rhodes: Yeah. I think you’re right. In discussion earlier, like I— probably those that are under construction right now, like already have those permits, are probably gonna keep going, which is not a small number of them, so we’re still gonna have some data centers energized, you know, in the next few months over 2027. But in terms of data centers and kind of like, again, we touched about this a little bit before, but kind of in paying their own way, do you think that going from like a 4CP to a 12CP or minimum transmission charge is enough? One thing that’s been pointed out to me is like if you really wanna ensure that like residential, commercial, everyone else is not paying for infrastructure for data centers, then it just can never make it into that rate base, right? It’s like the rate— like the pot of money that is like there’s a regulated rate of return on that gets allocated as fixed charges on bills. Is there a separate way of doing that, having a side pot that never makes it into like the main pot or like the data centers would just pay for so you could say that like this money never touched each other? Does that make sense?
Eric Goff: Yeah. I mean, the great thing about utility regulation is you can make it as complicated as you want to. But at the end of the day, I think multiple parties agree that, you know, minimum transmission charges for data centers, depending on the level you set of that, are more than capable of, you know, the data centers paying more than the cost of the transmission that was built for them. And, you know, I don’t think any company would wanna say, “Please charge me double,” you know? But on the other hand, I’m sure they’d be willing to pay a little bit more than the cost, right, in order to develop that social license. And on the distribution side, you know, data centers, for the most part, are connected at transmission voltage, and, you know, while there’s some cloud stuff that’s probably distribution or, you know, maybe there’s some inference stuff that’s distribution, and that’s a growing area, a lot of the distribution system is just growing in cost regardless of the data centers. And that’s something that really needs to be looked at. And then there’s the energy side, you know. In a competitive energy market, data centers are— tend to be installing, you know, new equipment, more solar, more batteries, more natural gas, and those could operate in a way that’s more efficient, especially if they’re all, you know, ideally in parallel and then dispatched through SCED. You have more resources to get to the least-cost solution that are maybe more efficient. So we could see lower transmission costs. We could see lower energy costs, but, you know, it’s— who knows? It’s a real challenge. We can guarantee on the transmission side that if you connect enough data centers, they’ll be able to more than pay for the transmission costs, and that’s the one place that, you know, you can feel some certainty.
Joshua Rhodes: Yeah. We’ll see, but it’s like, you know, it’s always that old adage, if once you’re explaining, you’re losing, right? So it’s like we’ll see if that message can kinda make it through. We won’t go back to it, but, like, I think a lot of the companies want some kind of like, you know, merge between, like, the PCLR, the Provisional Controllable Load Resource, and the Withdrawal-Limited Private Use Network, WLPUN. Like want some kind of merge of those two to have that where load and the generation’s able to kind of play.
Eric Goff: That’s gonna be really critical. If the rules get in the way of people making good decisions, then you need to change the rules. And having, you know, maximum options for flexibility for people to bring their own generation, not just for planning purposes, but for operations, you know? These large campuses are gonna be complicated, and it needs to be transparent and straightforward on how to operate and build them. And, you know, there’s even talk of allowing generators that are off-site from the data center to be able to contribute to helping the data center stay online. Generators can be DERs, which can be people’s home batteries. So it very well could see an impact where lots of people get home batteries as a result of the data center process if we do it right.
Joshua Rhodes: We had Base Power on to talk about a study they did with Piq Energy that kinda looked at, you know, the ability of, you know, distributed batteries to kind of alleviate contingencies and, you know, congestion and other types of grid constraints. That was really interesting. So one last thing on data centers, which we’ll probably talk about it again because you can’t not, but like one last thing on data centers. So one of the bills that’s already been filed, SB 293, it’s already got a bunch of bipartisan support, I believe just wiping out the incentives for data centers. And so do you think the legislature will go further than that? Or is like— where do you see, you know, any kind of incentives being cut for data centers?
Eric Goff: Yeah, that’s a good question. I think that those incentives are, you know, broadly unpopular. They’re tough to explain. What would generate a ton of revenue, if you add it up, though, the sum of like property taxes and the proposed sales and use taxes puts the cost of development like well above other states. And so I think there’s room to raise more revenue, but you don’t want to go so far that, you know, people don’t develop at all in the state, ‘cause then what a lost opportunity. I hope that tax experts, and I’m not a tax expert, offer very good and thoughtful advice on how to square that circle. I do think people are expecting to pay more. It’s just a question of exactly how to do that.
Joshua Rhodes: Yeah. I think that bill was really put in place in 2015, and it was roughly around $10 to $15 million or something per year. But I think that’s— now with these Nvidia chips costing, you know, 10,000 bucks a pop, it’s— the number’s definitely gone up. Let’s turn to, you know, transmission, affordability, market design, you know, things like that. Another hot contentious item in the Texas energy space has been the 765, you know, transmission build-out, particularly, you know, there’s tension between getting infrastructure built, protecting landowners. Like, do you see the blue wave in Texas affecting any of the build-out of that infrastructure?
Eric Goff: Yeah. So in terms of transmission, the leading supporter of new rules for transmission approval is Dan Patrick, and he didn’t win his election. And but just like practically, transmission lines affect the people that are relatively close to them, and then once it’s over the horizon, you’re not even aware of it. And so just from a geometry perspective, there’s not a lot of people that are affected by 765 transmission lines. And, you know, we’re getting better at building those transmission lines, so I wouldn’t be surprised for us to be able to see them, you know, take up less space as, you know, we start to innovate in that area again, ‘cause it’s just been so long since we’ve built any of them. So I expect there’ll be some pushback on that. You know, I hope that we don’t have a bill that, you know, makes it more difficult to build a certain kind of voltage level, because I would like to leave that to the engineers. But, you know, there are people that testified to say that they got notifications from the utility in unmarked white envelopes, and that certainly needs to change, right? You need to know what it is that you get in the mail. That’s a basic due process thing. I’ve talked to a lot of attorneys that are in those cases that say 180 days isn’t enough for a complicated case. I would hope that there’s a way to figure out what a complicated case is and say those need to take more time. But, you know, bread-and-butter transmission lines, add an extra six months just adds time and costs and doesn’t really achieve anything. So I’ll be really curious to see who pursues, you know, any increased barriers to building that transmission infrastructure. I think it’ll certainly be less of a priority than it would’ve been if Vikki Goodwin hadn’t won the election. Vikki Goodwin and Gina Hinojosa are all people that come from a tradition of, you know, wanting to care about community impacts and concerns, so I think they’ll be similarly do that on transmission, but also understand that transmission gets a lot of energy flowing around the state, including what could be new businesses, new clean generation. And I think they’ll ultimately let it move forward. I do think it’s interesting, one of the things that Vikki Goodwin said on the campaign trail about data centers was she wanted to protect the people and the animals that live near them, and that’s just not something we’ve heard a lot in Texas lately.
Joshua Rhodes: That’s true. I must have missed that one. So what do you think that the election will mean for generation resources, like renewable energy, battery storage, distributed energy, and other types of infrastructure? In past legislative sessions, we’ve seen bills come through that have, you know, sought to, you know, restrict development of renewables and storage. Do you see those bills still coming through, not making it as far as they have in the past, or do you see more pro bills coming through? Like, what do you think the election means for renewables in Texas?
Eric Goff: Yeah. I think that it’ll be much more difficult to pass bills that hurt, you know, wind and solar and batteries. There’s always been threats of that. In the last several sessions we’ve seen, you know, bills that required to do studies of the cost of ancillary services with the assumption that if you did cost causation, it would lower consumer costs and raise costs for renewable generators. And ERCOT and the PUC just did a study to say actually that wouldn’t lower costs for consumers. But the reason it was in there in the first place was, you know, kinda anti one class of technology. So those bills won’t pass, and on the other hand, it might be easier to do process reforms for, you know, DER interconnections or, you know, other things that are just practically more straightforward. A lot of batteries come off assembly lines these days, and so maybe there are ways to speed up the interconnection process for those. I don’t think the industry, you know, is gonna go stray too far from the technology-neutral approach that, you know, we’ve had for a while. But there certainly won’t be any anti bills that pass when they wouldn’t get through the House. And if they did, they’d be vetoed, I would assume.
Joshua Rhodes: Yeah. No, I see. I’ve been asked that question too, and it’s kind of one of those, like, well, I mean, Texas has more wind than the next four states combined, more solar and storage than California. It’s like, without any mandates, it’s like, “if it ain’t broke, don’t fix it” mentality. But that’s been my, you know, five-second elevator pitch response. But in terms of market design, we still haven’t implemented, like, all of the bits and pieces for all the various, you know, bills and studies and other things like that that we’ve been working on since post-Winter Storm Uri. In particular, kinda this Dispatchable Reliability Reserve Service, or DRRS. Where is that right now, and do you think where it goes will change based on now how the powers that be are changing hands?
Eric Goff: So as someone that in the past has been an advocate for DRRS, one of my biggest regrets is asking that we put an ancillary service into state law. It’s just so complicated, and it’s better done, you know, in the realm of market design. But the DRRS is yet to be implemented. ERCOT is saying it might be the middle of next year, and there were, you know, two kinds of DRRS. There’s the one that I would characterize as like a bread-and-butter uncertainty ancillary service, like non-spin, ERCOT Contingency Reserve Service. And then there is a version called DRRS Plus, which was a pseudo-capacity-style market where the cost of entry would be entered into the calculation and generators would earn just for existing. And there was a threat during the resource adequacy debates that we would see that come up again. The way that it would get money to pay for that would be to crush the real-time price and take money away from wind and solar. And so I don’t see that one getting anywhere in this, you know, new world. And that’s good ‘cause it was not a great idea. I was arguing about it in the ERCOT stakeholder process for a while. But we probably will see more ancillary services procured as a result of all the load growth. Ancillary services are paid for on a load ratio share, and so you, as you add more buyers and you add more ancillary services, the cost per could still say stay about the same or lower, right? But we’ll be spending more overall money on them. And, you know, we might need to change the ancillary services demand curves. ERCOT has said recently that they’re worried about the operational complexities of curtailing a bunch of data centers, you know, before an emergency when they need to do something based on a forecast. You know, one way to do that in a market-based approach would be to procure enough ancillary services so ERCOT does have the time to respond during emergencies. I think that’s really straightforward and obvious, and I think we’ll probably end up doing that. I’m still an advocate of raising the offer cap. I think it would result in lower cost for consumers, you know, but there are some things I might be having to say a long time. Hopefully, that’s not one of them, but I wouldn’t be surprised.
Joshua Rhodes: Well, some things that people have been wanting for a long time happened in this past election, so, you know, you never know. You know, one of the issues we’ve seen in other places that have a lot of large loads like data centers is, you know, if a data center trips offline, that can be just as bad as a power plant tripping offline. And when I used to teach these types of things in class, I actually used to skip over that part of like, if you’ve got too much supply and not enough demand, that’s easy to solve. Like, that’s not a big deal. But when it’s like that much, that can be a big issue. Do you think some of these new ancillary services are going to have to have some kind of like spatial component or spatial aspect to them? I’ve been hearing rumblings of this. If you’ve got a bunch of data centers in a bunch of areas, like you might need those resources close by.
Eric Goff: Yeah. So ERCOT is worried about this, and for those that are in the weeds, this is a voltage ride-through concern, where if there’s a fault in the grid and the data centers trip offline, you could upset frequency, and it could lead to cascading outages and even a total blackout. No one wants that to happen, and so ERCOT’s imposing voltage ride-through requirements on data centers. We don’t do retroactive laws, and so there are some existing large loads that don’t have voltage ride-through. And so ERCOT is saying in a few areas, if the load from, you know, loads that can’t ride through go too much, we’re gonna have to curtail those loads. As part of the study that they were doing for that, they included more generators in the model, for at one point in some early results, and that resulted in higher limits, which shows that batteries in those areas can directly help to address that problem, right? So that’d be interesting to see if they did that. It would kind of be inefficient, though, I think, for anything but a highly specialized ancillary service. I think it would be better if just real-time co-optimization knew, you know, where energy and ancillary services were necessary, and then co-optimize to put those in the best places. And we kinda do that now. There could be some locational component of that, you know, with RTC, without having to create, like, zonal boundaries. So we’ll see. Location matters a lot for congestion. It doesn’t matter that much for frequency.
Joshua Rhodes: Yeah. Okay. All right, so let’s zoom out a little bit. We’ve talked mostly about electricity, but things like the Public Utility Commission, you know, ERCOT aren’t the only ones affected by the blue wave. We actually have a Democratic railroad commissioner for the first time. We’ve got, you know, Democrats won, you know, Court of Appeals and new appointments. And as we were talking about, appointments that the governor makes will impact how decisions are made at, like, places like the Texas Commission on Environmental Quality, you know, Office of the Public Utility Counsel, Texas Water Development Board. What do you think we will see in the next 12 months regarding those other parts of the system?
Eric Goff: Yeah. So just like the PUC, the appointment clock plays out in most of those as well. And so it depends on where the turnover happens and, you know, as the turnover’s happening, those, all those commissions and groups will be bipartisan in some way. Obviously, the Railroad Commission’s elected, and with just one Democrat, I wouldn’t expect much to change there. TCEQ has the ability to, in some cases, have some discretion over some of the larger permits, but still has to be compliant with the Clean Air Act. So I don’t think that, you know, the Clean Air Act applies to TCEQ today, it will tomorrow, and I don’t think they’ll be able to, you know, reject natural gas wholesale without some sort of change in law, right? So in areas where you meet the requirements, they’re probably gonna continue to get those permits and maybe tighten up rules, tighten up filing requirements. Legislation would require getting through the Senate. So, you know, you can only do so much without a change in law. On water, though, I mentioned earlier that Democrats are gonna look for big wins, and Texas Water Development Board exists to spend money and has authority to do that. And then also the comptroller, Sarah Eckhardt, is going to be able to spend some, probably some federal money that exists still from the IRA for energy efficiency uses. Those are some near-term things that they’ll be able to do, and they’ll probably be like seeking out, you know, unfunded things in the water development plans and trying to get those built. And, you know, not to make it about data centers again, but data centers also might wanna fund some water infrastructure in some cases there they are.
Joshua Rhodes: Yeah, I’ve heard of some, you know, wholesale replacing wastewater treatment facilities in other places and other things like that, if they’re able to. So zooming out even a little bit further beyond Texas electricity, Texas energy, like there’s a bigger blue wave kind of at the federal level. The US House and Senate are both now controlled by Democrats, including Texas sending James Talarico to the Senate. What do you think the blue wave at the federal level will mean for Texas regards to energy in particular?
Eric Goff: Well, James Talarico said he didn’t want to go up there to, you know, do a bunch of investigations or things like that. He wanted to focus on passing laws that affected affordability. I’m sure he and others will do their share of investigations, but I think they have a strong temptation to, you know, now that they’re in power to, you know, research everything, I know that they will. So, you know, this is an energy podcast, but I, you know, I would bet a large amount of money there’s gonna be hearings about ICE, right? But in terms of, you know, energy, in that case, you couldn’t pass anything unless, you know, the president was willing to sign it for the next few years, right? President Trump, I think, is as much of a maverick in different ways that John McCain was, and so I wouldn’t be surprised for him to wanna do a deal with the Democrats on some issues, and he’s talked about that. Maybe we’ll see permitting reform. I don’t know if it’ll be the same permitting bill that we saw previously that’s got, you know, some hair on it, but we might see that. We might see transmission planning happen at a larger scale to move power around the country, and that would be exciting. But I think it’d be difficult to get things done. You know, Washington’s such a partisan place. I’ve talked to a congressperson who shall remain nameless who said, “It’s tough to be one of a bunch of people,” you know? One individual congressperson can’t do a lot, and it’s a collective action problem.
Joshua Rhodes: Yeah. I know that, like, you know, folks outside of Texas who are in the energy circles have been having a lot of discussions around permit reform. I think it’s, like, BAAJA and Baja Blast, or I don’t know. So I’ve been seeing this, like, on the periphery, but, like, I haven’t really been paying that close of attention to it. And if you haven’t either, that’s fine, but, like, if permitting reform were to pass at the federal level, what impacts would that have in Texas?
Eric Goff: It depends. On the electric market, not a lot. You know, we have our own processes for doing things and, you know, we’re not FERC jurisdictional. But I know that there’s a lot of plans for building new transmission up in the Panhandle in the SPP area, and that might be easier. That’d be great. And I know Entergy Texas is also very interested in serving large load and, you know, growing communities out there.
Joshua Rhodes: Out in Southeast Texas?
Eric Goff: Yep.
Joshua Rhodes: The eastern part of Southeast, yeah.
Eric Goff: I hope that, you know, the bigger question around large-scale transmission projects would really just unlock the West. The West is just so subdivided and hard to get anything done. There’s a real need for governance reform in the Western power market and utilities. And figuring out transmission would be an unlock for that because they’d have to cooperate.
Joshua Rhodes: Yeah. No, absolutely. Well, just they’d have to cooperate ‘cause those lines, you know, bring us together and tie us all together. I think it’s a good place to stop. Eric Goff, thanks for coming back on the Energy Capital Podcast.
Eric Goff: My pleasure. Thanks for having me.










